Italian Dining on Anna Maria Island
Anna Maria Island is a culinary gem, especially for lovers of Italian cuisine. From cozy cafes to upscale restaurants, the island offers a wide range of Italian dining experiences that cater to every palate. Here’s a guide to some of the best Italian spots on Anna Maria Island and nearby areas.
DINING OPTIONS ON ANNA MARIA ISLAND
Discover the Best Italian Restaurants on Anna Maria Island and Bradenton
Anna Maria Island is home to a variety of Italian restaurants, each offering unique and authentic dining experiences. Some of the best Italian Restaurant on Anna Maria Island can be found here. There’s something to satisfy every Italian cuisine lover. Here are some top picks for the best Italian dining on the island and in nearby Bradenton.
Rating: 4.3 (176 reviews) · $10–20 · Restaurant
Holmes Beach, FL
Review Highlight: "Absolutely the best Italian restaurant on AMI!"
Rating: 4.3 (432 reviews) · $$ · Italian
Holmes Beach, FL
Services: Dine-in, Curbside Pickup, No Delivery
Oma's Pizza and Italian Restaurant
Rating: 3.9 (1.8K reviews) · $10–20 · Italian
Bradenton Beach, FL
Services: Counter-serve
Rating: 5.0 (84 reviews) · $10–20 · Italian
Bradenton Beach, FL
Services: Dine-in
Rating: 4.7 (558 reviews) · $10–20 · Pizza
Anna Maria, FL
Review Highlight: "Can’t say enough about the Italian Sausage."
Rating: 4.4 (202 reviews) · $10–20 · Restaurant
Holmes Beach, FL
Review Highlight: "Classic Italian restaurant setup made me feel like I was in Cicero, IL."
Rating: 3.5 (128 reviews) · $10–20 · Pizza
Holmes Beach, FL
Services: Dine-in, Takeout, Delivery
New Italian Restaurant on Anna Maria Island is this hidden gem
One of the few restaurants on Anna Maria Island that take reservations and have live music
Rating: 5.0 (21 reviews) · $50–100 · Restaurant
Holmes Beach, FL
Services: Dine-in, Takeout
Rating: 4.5 (377 reviews) · $50–100 · Restaurant
· Holmes Beach, FL
The Porch Restaurant Anna Maria
Rating: 4.8 (562 reviews) · Restaurant
· Anna Maria, FL
Services: Dine-in, Takeout, No Delivery
Rating: 4.6 (3.1K reviews) · $$ · Seafood
Anna Maria, FL
Description: Beachside eatery with eclectic seafood
Ventura's Italian Kitchen & Wine Bar
Rating: 4.4 (170 reviews) · $20–30 · Italian
Longboat Key, FL
Services: Dine-in, Takeout, Delivery
Rating: 4.5 (654 reviews) · $10–20 · Italian
Holmes Beach, FL
Services: Takeout
Rating: 4.9 (119 reviews) · $10–20 · Italian
Bradenton Beach, FL
Services: Delivery