Best Ice Cream Shops On Anna Maria Island

Whether you're strolling the sun-drenched streets of Anna Maria Island or winding down after a beach day, there's nothing quite like a cold, creamy scoop of ice cream. From classic favorites to artisanal gelato and fruity Italian ice, the island and its nearby towns are full of delightful dessert stops. Here's your ultimate guide to the best ice cream shops on Anna Maria Island.

Our Top Picks for Ice Cream on Anna Maria Island

1. Two Scoops – Anna Maria, FL

4.7 (1.3K reviews) · $$ · Ice Cream
“Large variety of delicious ice cream flavors served with a smile.”

Located steps from the beach, Two Scoops is a fan favorite for good reason. With generous portions, fun flavors, and a welcoming vibe, it's perfect for families and couples alike.

2. Tyler’s Homemade Ice Cream – Cortez, FL

4.7 (1.1K reviews) · $ · Ice Cream
“The black raspberry ice cream was delicious and the staff is friendly!”

This small-batch creamery has been churning out quality treats since 1984. Don’t miss their seasonal specialties and handmade waffle cones.

3. Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff – Holmes Beach, FL

4.6 (473 reviews) · Ice Cream
“The ice cream was perfectly creamy, with just the right amount of sweetness.”

Holy Cow is known for its quirky decor, refreshing sweets, and fun gift shop. A must-visit after dinner or during your afternoon walk.

4. AMI Beach Hut – Anna Maria, FL

4.8 (71 reviews) · Ice Cream
“They had a great selection of ice cream and the flavor was incredible!”

Some of The Best Ice Cream Shops On Anna Maria Island Can Be Found Here

• Dips Ice Cream – Anna Maria, FL
  Great atmosphere and a variety of classic flavors.

• Anna Maria Island Creamery and Bakery – Anna Maria, FL
  Delicious desserts and friendly service with a bakery bonus.

Post Beach Italian Ice – Anna Maria, FL
The Italian Ice is amazing and perfect for a hot day.