Best Seafood Dining on Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island is a slice of paradise on Florida’s Gulf Coast, known for its laid-back atmosphere, sandy beaches, and mouthwatering cuisine. For many visitors, no trip is complete without sampling the island’s fresh catch. From grouper sandwiches to shrimp tacos and classic fish and chips, seafood restaurants on Anna Maria Island deliver some of the best food on the Gulf.

If you’re searching for the best seafood restaurants Anna Maria Island Florida has to offer, here’s a guide to top-rated favorites locals and visitors rave about.

The Blue Marlin | Seafood Restaurant

A staple in Bradenton Beach, The Blue Marlin is one of the top-rated seafood restaurants Anna Maria Island has to offer. Known for its rustic Florida charm and cozy atmosphere, this restaurant serves freshly caught grouper, shrimp, and other Gulf favorites. Their “Tater Tot Shrimp” is a local favorite, and their outdoor “Trap Yard” offers live music and a relaxed vibe that perfectly captures the island lifestyle.

Floridays Woodfire Grill & Bar

For a more casual yet upscale experience, Floridays Woodfire Grill & Bar is a must. Located at Compass Hotel by Margaritaville, this spot features an open-air dining experience with stunning water views. The menu highlights woodfire-grilled fish, shrimp, and oysters, making it a top pick for those craving the best seafood in Anna Maria Island.

Anna Maria Oyster Bar – Bridge Street

Perfect place to grab a bit to eat and enjoy views of the bay.

Fish and Chips Restaurants Anna Maria Island

No seafood guide would be complete without a nod to the island’s classic fish and chips restaurants Anna Maria Island visitors love. Whether you’re enjoying a golden, crispy grouper sandwich at a beachside café or a generous plate of fried cod with hand-cut fries, the island takes this simple dish to the next level. Many local favorites—including The Blue Marlin and Anna Maria Oyster Bar—offer their own take on this classic.

Why Anna Maria Island is a Seafood Lover’s Paradise

When it comes to best seafood dining on Anna Maria Island, the options range from casual oyster bars to waterfront grills with sunset views. The island’s commitment to serving fresh, locally caught fish ensures that every meal is an authentic taste of Florida’s Gulf Coast. Whether you’re looking for fine dining or a relaxed atmosphere, the best seafood restaurants Anna Maria Island has to offer guarantee an unforgettable experience.

Final Bite

If you’re planning a trip to Anna Maria Island, make sure to try at least one of these seafood restaurants Anna Maria Island Florida is known for. From the charm of The Blue Marlin to the lively vibe of Anna Maria Oyster Bar, each restaurant brings something unique to the table. And for seafood lovers, Anna Maria Island truly serves up some of the best food on Anna Maria Island.