Best Burgers on Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island may be best known for its pristine beaches, laid-back charm, and fresh Florida seafood, but sometimes nothing hits the spot like a juicy burger. Whether you’re craving a classic cheeseburger, a gourmet twist, or an island-style creation paired with a cold beer, AMI has plenty of options. From long-standing local taverns to beachside grills, here’s your ultimate guide to the best burger on Anna Maria Island. Check out the Skinny’s V. Duffy’s Burger Challenge.

1. Skinny’s Place – A Local Landmark

If you ask a longtime local where to find the best burger on Anna Maria Island, chances are they’ll point you to Skinny’s Place. This family-owned burger shack has been serving fresh, no-frills burgers since the 1950s.

• Classic cheeseburgers with perfectly toasted buns

• Ice-cold beer and laid-back island vibes

• Across from Manatee Public Beach

It’s a must-stop for anyone craving an authentic “old Florida” experience.

2. Duffy’s Tavern – “Hamburger Heaven”

Known for its slogan, “The coldest beer and the best burgers in town, Duffy’s Tavern has been an AMI favorite for over 40 years. This family-owned spot has even earned national recognition for its burgers.

• Simple, no-frills menu with burgers cooked to perfection

• Potato salad and collard greens are local favorites on the side

• A true locals’ hangout with a vintage tavern feel

3. The Porch Restaurant – Gourmet Burger Vibes

If you’re in the mood for something a little more upscale, The Porch Restaurant delivers. With high ratings and a menu that elevates the traditional burger, it’s a top choice for foodies.

• Brie-stuffed burgers and other creative variations

• Elegant indoor and outdoor dining spaces

• Great option for pairing burgers with cocktails or wine
  

4. Smoqehouse – Burgers with a Twist

Smoqehouse brings bold, smoky flavors to AMI, offering a different take on the classic burger. This is where craft and creativity meet comfort food.

• BBQ-inspired burgers with unique toppings

• Fresh, high-quality ingredients

• Casual yet trendy dining atmosphere

5. Harry’s Grill – Burgers & Live Music

For a fun night out, Harry’s Grill combines great burgers with live music and a lively crowd. Voted a “best burger” on Anna Maria Island multiple times, it’s a favorite among both visitors and locals.

• Signature burgers with creative toppings

• 16 imported and craft beers on tap

• Live music almost every evening

6. Hurricane Hanks – A Local Favorite in Holmes Beach

Not far from the heart of the island, Hurricane Hanks has built a reputation for one of the juiciest burgers in Manatee County. Known for its consistency, it’s the kind of place where you know the burger will be good every time.

• Thick, flavorful patties cooked to order

• Casual pub-style dining

• Perfect for families or groups

FAQs About Burgers on Anna Maria Island

What is the best burger on Anna Maria Island?
It depends on your style! For classic island charm, head to Skinny’s Place. For a no-frills tavern burger, Duffy’s is king. And if you’re looking for gourmet, The Porch is your best bet.

Is there an In-N-Out Burger on Anna Maria Island?
No, you won’t find In-N-Out here. But trust us—the local burger joints more than make up for it.

What’s the nicest part of Anna Maria Island for dining?
Pine Avenue in Anna Maria and Bridge Street in Bradenton Beach are both top spots with plenty of restaurants, bars, and burger joints nearby.

Is Marco Island or Anna Maria Island better for foodies?
Both offer great dining, but Anna Maria Island is known for its unique, locally owned restaurants rather than chain spots, making it a foodie paradise.

Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a seasoned local, these restaurants prove that Anna Maria Island isn’t just about seafood—it’s also home to some of the best burgers in Florida’s Gulf Coast. From Skinny’s Place to Duffy’s Tavern and beyond, there’s a burger here for every craving.