AMI FL Sealife: Dolphins, Manatees and Sea Turtles
As a guy who runs his network 24 hours a day on 4 active domains, works a full-time job as a pool guy, and spends weekends as a deckhand near the Waterline Marina and Keyes Marina area—sometimes as second mate on the big Dream Cat on public dolphin tours—I am the one taking your pictures. If "Billy" was your second mate, you literally got to Seas The Day for free. I have been honing my skills as a photographer out on the water: rolling waves, no tripod, just the blue water, a sunset, and smiling people.
Off the Wall: Tales from the Florida Pool Truck Guy
With all that in mind, I love to read and learn things. Taking a job as a deckhand teaches me the ropes literally as someday I wish to sail off into the big blue—I need to practice tying off at the cleat. So here is my local, on-the-ground reality on the sea life right here on AMI.
Anna Maria Island Dolphins
Dolphins are one of my absolute favorites to learn about. The resident bottlenose dolphins here are among the most thoroughly studied dolphins in the world. The Sarasota Dolphin Research Program (SDRP)—operated by Brookfield Zoo Chicago in partnership with Mote Marine Laboratory—has been studying them for over 50 years.
They love the area because of the vast grass beds and sheltered, shallow water. The local resident population sits right near 150 individuals.
One well-known resident is Mangels—a mature male who lost his long-time male alliance ("bromance") partner and now operates as a solo drifter working the flats alone or spending time with the ladies. He got his name from what researchers say is a propeller scar on his dorsal fin, so please respect the sea life out here.
So yes, they call Sarasota Bay, Anna Maria Sound, and lower Tampa Bay home year-round. Will you see dolphins on AMI? Yes, but the truth is, you've got to put your phone down and scan the water—they are quick. Some of the best land-based viewing spots are near any of the local piers at sunrise or along Longboat Pass when the tide is moving.
Where to See Manatees on Anna Maria Island
Manatees are much harder to spot. They surface gracefully—often showing just a snout to catch a breath—and dip right back down. If you’re lucky, you might catch a tail flip. Instead of making a big splash, they tend to leave smooth, subtle "footprint" ripples on the water's surface.
Spotting them on AMI takes patience and heavy scouting. You have to lock in and scan the water like you're at a local club looking for that special someone—dialed in where nothing else matters.
The Best Spot to See Manatees on AMI
As a local dockhand, I can tell you a prime spot: check the shared marina basin between Keyes Marina and Waterline Marina. It's a well-protected basin. When charter captains bring their boats back in and flush their engines to clear out the saltwater, local manatees gather right in that area.
Usually daily, they hang around to drink the fresh water coming off the engine flush lines or from the storm drain near the walkway. They are right there up front and beautiful. There is a mama manatee with a calf that frequents that protected basin, along with a massive 10-to-11-foot resident manatee featuring three distinct propeller scars across its back.
There are even some massive resident snook that call that marina basin home and use it as their hunting grounds. It doesn't cost anything to walk around, but you need patience and the ability to scan the water closely.
AMI Sea Turtles
Sea turtles are well-documented on the island. They are a protected species at risk of losing their habitats to coastal development. They are even harder to spot in the water unless you have a well-trained eye scanning the surf line.
If you encounter hatchlings on the beach, do not touch or help them. Immediately call the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) 24-hour hotline at 1-888-404-3922.
If you are staying on the island during nesting season (May through October), make sure you turn off exterior lights at night or verify your property uses turtle-compliant amber/red lighting. Avoid local rental scams on AMI by staying smart and asking questions about property compliance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are there resident dolphins on Anna Maria Island?
Yes. Over 150 resident bottlenose dolphins live year-round in the bays and coastal waters around Anna Maria Island. Many are recognized individually by researchers and local captains through fin markings and scars.
Are there alligators on Anna Maria Island?
Alligators are rare on the island itself. Because Anna Maria Island is surrounded by saltwater Gulf and Bay waters, the local ecosystem is dominated by marine species like dolphins, manatees, sea turtles, and coastal sea birds rather than freshwater reptiles.
What is the best way to see wildlife on AMI?
Walking the shorelines at sunrise, checking the local piers, watching quiet marina basins during boat flushes, or joining an eco-tour with experienced local captains offers the best vantage point for observing natural wildlife behavior without disrupting the animals.

